CSA scores don't punish fleets for having trucks. They punish fleets for having defects that reach the roadside. In FMCSA's Safety Measurement System, the Vehicle Maintenance BASIC is built from violations found during inspections: brakes, lights, tires, cargo securement and missing inspection or repair records. Every one of those violations began as a defect somewhere upstream, in a pre-trip, a DVIR or a missed PM. This guide explains how the score is built, which levers you control, and a 90-day plan to work them, then shows how Truck Inspection & Maintenance Management Software (TIM) keeps those levers moving. Start free and catch defects before an inspector does.

CSA Scores · Vehicle Maintenance · Fleet Compliance

How to Improve CSA Scores: Fleet Maintenance & Compliance Guide

Most roadside maintenance violations are defects that were visible days earlier. TIM helps you find them first: guided driver inspections with photos, defects that become work orders with an owner, and PM scheduled by interval, so more problems get fixed in your shop and fewer get found at the scale.

ViolationsWhat inspectors find
×
SeverityHow serious each is
×
RecencyHow recent it is
÷
ExposureYour fleet and inspections

How the Score Is Built (and Where You Have Control)

SMS looks at roadside inspection violations from the past 24 months, weights each by how serious and how recent it is, and compares the result to carriers with similar inspection activity. Your percentile is a ranking, so a lower number is better. You can't change the formula, but you can influence every input.

1Find fewer violationsCatch defects in your own inspections so there is less for an officer to find.
2Avoid the severe onesPrioritize safety-critical defects such as brakes, tires and lighting, which carry heavier weights.
3Let time work for youNewer violations count for more. Clean months push the older ones down.
4Keep inspections cleanA roadside inspection with no violations counts in your favor.

The Recency Ladder: Why Fixing Things Now Matters Most

A violation doesn't count the same forever. In the current SMS methodology, recent violations are weighted more heavily, so a clean stretch helps over time.

0 to 6 months old

Weighted 3×
6 to 12 months old

Weighted 2×
12 to 24 months old

Weighted 1×

Based on SMS methodology version 3.21. Violations drop out of the calculation after 24 months. Always check FMCSA's current methodology document.

What's changing FMCSA approved enhancements to SMS in November 2024, including splitting Vehicle Maintenance into two categories: Vehicle Maintenance and Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed, the latter covering items a driver could reasonably spot on a walkaround. As of early November 2026, the enhanced methodology hasn't launched and carriers are still scored on the seven BASICs. Check FMCSA's SMS site for the latest. Either way, daily inspection quality matters.

From Violation to Fix: Where Maintenance Violations Come From

The Vehicle Maintenance BASIC covers the parts and records an inspector checks. For each area, there is a daily habit that prevents the violation.

Violation areaWhat prevents itHow TIM helps
Brakes Daily brake checks, adjustment and replacement by condition Failed brake items become work orders with photos
Lights and reflectors Full light check in every pre-trip Lamp checkpoints in the guided inspection, bulbs flagged and fixed
Tires and wheels Tread depth and pressure checks, damage inspection Tire findings logged per truck, so wear patterns show up
Cargo securement Securement check before departure Securement included as an inspection checkpoint
Inspection, repair and maintenance records Annual inspections on time, DVIRs certified, maintenance files complete Due dates, defect tracking and service history on each unit
Coupling and suspension Walkaround of fifth wheel, landing gear and suspension Guided walkaround covers each component in order

Make Every Defect Someone's Job

Inspections, DVIR defects, work orders and PM on one record per truck, so what a driver sees on Monday is fixed before an officer sees it on Friday.

A 90-Day Plan to Work the Levers

Scores move gradually because the window is 24 months long. These three phases build habits that show up in your data over time. They don't promise a specific score.

Days 1 to 30Baseline
  • Review your last 24 months of inspections and violations on the SMS site
  • Rank violation areas by frequency and severity
  • Check for data errors and file DataQs requests where a record is wrong
  • Set a standard pre-trip checklist for every driver
Days 31 to 60Fix the top three
  • Target your three most common violation areas
  • Route every reported defect to a work order with an owner
  • Close the loop: certify repairs before the truck rolls
  • Coach drivers on the checkpoints that keep getting missed
Days 61 to 90Lock it in
  • Schedule PM by interval for every unit
  • Review repeat defects by truck and find the root cause
  • Track on-time PM and open defects weekly
  • Repeat the SMS review and compare to your baseline

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do violations affect my CSA score?
SMS uses the past 24 months of inspection data. Recent violations are weighted more heavily than older ones, so a stretch of clean inspections helps your measure over time. Book a demo to see how TIM tracks defects before they become violations.
Can I get a violation removed?
If a record is incorrect, you can ask for a review through FMCSA's DataQs system. A valid violation stays on the record, so the lasting fix is preventing the defect in the first place.
Are CSA scores public?
For property carriers, percentiles and alerts aren't shown to the public, but inspection and violation data are. Carriers can see their own SMS results by logging in. Insurers, shippers and brokers may still look at the underlying data.
Will improving maintenance lower my score right away?
Not immediately. Fewer defects lead to fewer violations at future inspections, and the score responds as older violations age out and clean inspections accumulate. Think in months, not days. Start free and build the habits that move the data.
Inspect · Fix · Verify · Repeat

Find It Before the Inspector Does

Put inspections, defects, work orders and PM in one system, and every truck's status is a tap away instead of a search through clipboards and spreadsheets.

No credit card required. Free for up to 3 trucks. Built for FMCSA-compliant fleets.